Methodology

How we turn lab reports into comparable specs

Every figure on a CBDSpecs review comes from a certificate of analysis (COA) issued by a third-party laboratory accredited to ISO/IEC 17025. This page explains what we accept, what we calculate, and what we refuse to publish.

1. What counts as a valid COA

A COA is used only if all of the following can be checked:

  • Independent laboratory: the report is issued by a lab that is not owned by the brand.
  • ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation: we record the lab name and its accreditation number. We check the accreditation in the public directory of the body that issued it whenever that directory can be consulted. When it cannot, we rely on at least two independent sources, such as the accreditation statement on the report or the laboratory’s website and a third-party listing, and we check again with the accreditation body as soon as possible.
  • Batch and date: the report shows a batch or lot number and a test date, both recorded on the review.
  • Product match: the report covers the product we review (name, format and declared strength).
  • Public link: the COA is available to readers, and we link to it from the review.

If one of these points is missing, the review shows “No complete third-party COA on file” and no lab figure is displayed, even if the brand advertises one.

2. The figures we publish

FieldSourceHow it is shown
Total CBD (mg)COA concentration × declared net contentMilligrams per bottle, pack or jar
CBD per unit (mg)COAPer mL (oils, pets), per gummy, per capsule, per gram (topicals)
SpectrumCOA cannabinoid profileFull-Spectrum, Broad-Spectrum or Isolate
THC statusCOA total THC resultDetected (with the measured Δ9-THC percentage) or Not detected
ExtractionBrand documentationSupercritical CO2 or Ethanol
Price (USD)Retail price on the date checkedShown with the date it was checked
Cost per mg of CBDCalculatedPrice ÷ lab-verified total CBD

3. THC status, explained

  • Detected: the COA reports a quantified amount of THC (Δ9-THC, or THCA counted in total THC). The review shows the measured percentage by weight and the amount per container.
  • Not detected: no THC was found above the lab’s limit of detection or quantification as printed on the report. This describes the tested lot only and does not guarantee that a product contains no THC at all.

We report what the laboratory measured and do not label a product as legal or compliant. THC limits differ between countries and US states, some are expressed as a percentage and others per container, and they change over time. Check the rules where you live.

4. Rankings and category position

Within a category, the “Category position” panel ranks a product on two lab-based metrics: cost per mg of CBD (lower ranks higher) and concentration per unit (higher ranks higher). It appears only once a category has at least four published reviews, and a metric is shown only when at least four products have a lab-verified value. Ties are labelled as ties.

5. Rating grid

A rating out of 5 is published only for a product with a valid COA (section 1). It adds up five criteria worth one point each, and every criterion can be checked from the COA, the price and the brand’s public pages. The rating is shown with one decimal.

CriterionWhat we check1 point0.5 point0 points
Test coveragePanels on the COA of the reviewed lotPotency plus heavy metals, pesticides, residual solvents, microbiology and mycotoxins, all passedPotency plus at least two of those panels, all passedPotency only
Label accuracyGap between the lab’s total CBD and the strength printed on the labelWithin ±10 %Within ±20 %More than 20 %
COA ageTime between the report date and the date the price was checked12 months or less12 to 24 monthsMore than 24 months
ValueCost per mg of CBD against the median of lab-verified reviews in the same categoryAt or below the medianUp to 1.5 times the medianMore than 1.5 times the median
Lot traceabilityCan a buyer find the COA for the lot printed on their bottle?Yes: lot lookup, QR code or lab portal by lotCOAs are published but cannot be matched to a lotOnly a sample COA not tied to the lots on sale
  • When a rating is not shown: the value criterion needs a category median, so ratings appear once a category has at least four lab-verified reviews, like the category position panel. A COA with a failed contaminant panel gets no rating, and the review says which panel failed. A rating is also left out while one of the five criteria cannot be checked yet; we never fill a gap with an assumed score.
  • What a rating does not measure: taste, texture, packaging, how a product feels to use, any health outcome, customer reviews or brand reputation. A rating compares documentation, label accuracy and price. It does not say whether a product is effective, safe or suitable for you.
  • Calculation: the rating is plain arithmetic on recorded inputs (COA results, label strength, dates, price and the category median), like the cost per mg. Nothing is estimated, and each review lists the points given for every criterion.
  • Updates: a rating is recalculated when a newer COA is used, when the price is checked again, or when the category median changes.
  • Independence: affiliate commissions and brand relationships are not part of the grid and never change a rating.

6. What we never do

  • We never estimate, round “by eye” or invent a figure. A missing value stays missing.
  • We never copy a potency figure from a marketing page without a matching COA.
  • We never make or repeat health claims, and we do not give dosage advice.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if the label and the COA disagree?

We publish the lab figure and, when the brand states a different strength, we show both values with their sources so you can see the gap.

How often are COAs re-checked?

Each review shows the batch and test date of the COA it uses. When a brand publishes a newer COA for the product, we update the figures and the date.

How is the rating out of 5 calculated?

Five criteria worth one point each: test coverage, label accuracy, COA age, value against the category median, and lot traceability. Ratings appear once a category has at least four lab-verified reviews. They compare documentation and price, not effects.

Can a brand pay to be ranked higher?

No. Rankings follow the published lab figures and price. Affiliate relationships never change the data or the order.